A.A. Dewan & Co.

How to Submit a Response to a Trademark Show Cause Notice

A.A. Dewan & Co.
How to Submit a Response to a Trademark Show Cause Notice

Received a Trademark Show Cause Notice at IPO? Learn how to understand objections, prepare a legal reply, submit your response, and avoid costly mistakes that could put your application at risk.

Legally Reviewed

Reviewed by Ahmed Ali Dewan, Advocate Supreme Court of Pakistan.

This article is for general legal information in Pakistan and should not be treated as case-specific legal advice.

You applied for a trademark to protect your brand. Everything seemed fine until one day, a Show Cause Notice arrived from the Trade Marks Registry.

Now the questions begin.

Has my trademark been rejected? Did someone else register my brand? Will I lose my application? What should I do next?

For someone who filed a trademark application without professional assistance, receiving this notice can be worrying.

Some applicants ignore it, hoping the issue will resolve itself. Others attempt a reply but struggle to explain why their trademark should be accepted.

Unfortunately, ignoring the notice can put the entire application at risk.

The good news? A Show Cause Notice does not automatically mean your trademark has been rejected.

It means the Registrar has raised an objection that needs a proper response.

If you have received a trademark Show Cause Notice from the Intellectual Property Organization of Pakistan (IPO), this guide will help you:

  • Understand why the Registrar raised an objection.
  • Identify the legal grounds mentioned in the notice.
  • Prepare a proper trademark objection reply.
  • Respond to pending and registered trademark citations.
  • Address distinctiveness and geographical objections.
  • Understand the submission procedure.
  • Learn from a practical sample legal reply.

Most importantly, you will understand what to do before your trademark application is put at risk.

Received a Show Cause Notice? Start Here

The first thing you should do is read the notice carefully.

A Show Cause Notice is not simply a warning. It is a formal communication identifying a legal or procedural issue with your trademark application.

Under Section 27 of the Trade Marks Ordinance, 2001, the Registrar examines whether an application meets the requirements for registration.

If an objection arises, the applicant is given an opportunity to respond or make an appropriate amendment.

Check These Five Details First

Before preparing your reply, examine the following information:

  1. Application Number: Confirm that the notice relates to your trademark application.
  2. Trademark Details: Check the trademark name, representation and class.
  3. Legal Objection: Identify the section of law mentioned by the Registrar.
  4. Cited Trademark: Review any earlier pending application or registered trademark referred to in the notice.
  5. Response Deadline: Note the last date for taking the required action.

Remember: Do not start drafting a reply until you understand what the Trade Marks Registry is asking you to explain.

How Much Time Do You Have?

Time matters when responding to a trademark objection.

Under Rule 27(2) of the Trade Marks Rules, 2004, an applicant generally has two months from communication of the objection to take the required action.

Depending on the circumstances, the applicant may:

  • Submit written representations.
  • Make an appropriate amendment.
  • Request an opportunity of hearing.

If the applicant fails to act within the prescribed period, the application may be treated as abandoned.

IPO's published guidance also refers to a two-month response period for a Show Cause Notice.

Always verify the date of communication, the instructions in the notice and the applicable deadline.

Important: Filing a trademark application is only the beginning. Monitoring Registry communications is equally important.

Why Did IPO Raise an Objection?

Not every trademark objection is the same.

Some objections arise because the proposed mark resembles an earlier trademark. Others concern descriptive words, geographical terms, lack of distinctiveness or defects in the application.

Common Grounds for Objection

The Registrar may raise an objection based on:

  1. Earlier Pending Trademark: A previously filed trademark application may conflict with your proposed mark.
  2. Registered Trademark: An existing registration may create a legal obstacle.
  3. Lack of Distinctiveness: The proposed mark may not adequately distinguish your products or services.
  4. Geographical Terms: The mark may describe geographical origin.
  5. Descriptive or Common Words: The mark may consist of expressions commonly used in the relevant trade.
  6. Application Requirements: The application may contain deficiencies requiring clarification or amendment.

The important question is not simply:

Why was my trademark objected to?

It is:

Which legal ground applies, and how should that ground be answered?

For a broader explanation, read our guide to trademark objections and their legal grounds.

Below, we focus on preparing the response.

1. Objection Based on a Pending Trademark

Imagine applying for a brand called VELMORA.

The Registrar raises an objection because an earlier application for VELMORE is pending in the same or a related category of goods.

You discover that the cited trademark has not yet been registered.

Your first thought might be:

  • If the other trademark is still pending, why should it stop my application?
  • This is where many applicants misunderstand the law.

What Does the Law Say?

  • Section 17 of the Trade Marks Ordinance, 2001 deals with relative grounds for refusal, while Section 18 defines what may qualify as an earlier trademark.
  • Under Section 18(2), an earlier pending application may be relevant when determining a later application, subject to its eventual registration.

Therefore, a pending trademark cannot be dismissed merely because its registration has not yet been completed.

How Should You Reply?

Begin by examining the earlier application.

Step 1 – Verify the Cited Mark

Check:

  • Application number and filing date.
  • Priority details, where applicable.
  • Name of the applicant or proprietor.
  • Present application status.
  • Trademark representation.
  • Goods or services covered by the application.

Step 2 – Compare Both Trademarks

Consider the following questions:

  • Are the trademarks visually similar?
  • Do they sound alike?
  • Do they convey similar meanings?
  • Are the respective goods or services identical or similar?
  • Is there a legally relevant likelihood of confusion?

Step 3 – Prepare Your Legal Argument

If genuine differences exist, explain them clearly with reference to the statutory objection.

Avoid relying on assumptions or unsupported claims.

Sample Legal Argument

The applicant respectfully submits that the applied-for trademark VELMORA and the cited mark VELMORE differ in their overall commercial impressions for the following reasons: [insert the actual visual, phonetic and conceptual distinctions].

The applicant further submits that the respective goods or services and relevant trading circumstances are [insert verified details]. In view of these circumstances, the applicant requests reconsideration of the objection under the applicable provisions of Section 17.

This is only an illustrative argument. Similar-looking marks may still create a genuine legal conflict.

What Should You Avoid?

Do not simply write:

The cited trademark is pending, therefore it has no legal value.

That statement overlooks the relevance of Section 18(2).

Key Point: The status of the cited trademark matters, but your reply must also address the actual legal grounds for the objection.

2. Objection Based on a Registered Trademark

This situation requires particular care.

Suppose your proposed trademark is NOVENTA, while an earlier registered trademark is NOVENTO.

Both relate to closely connected products.

The Registrar may raise an objection under Section 17 of the Trade Marks Ordinance, 2001.

What Should You Check?

Start by examining the cited registration.

Verify:

  1. Registration Status: Whether the registration is relevant and legally effective.
  2. Ownership: Who owns the registered trademark.
  3. Goods or Services: What products or services the registration covers.
  4. Trademark Similarity: Whether the marks are identical or similar.
  5. Legal Conflict: Whether the statutory requirements involving earlier rights or likelihood of confusion are satisfied.

Changing a single letter does not necessarily make a trademark distinguishable from an earlier mark.

Similarly, placing goods in different trademark classes does not automatically eliminate a legal conflict.

How Should You Reply?

Your response should focus on the precise legal objection.

Where relevant, explain:

  • Differences in overall appearance.
  • Differences in pronunciation.
  • Differences in meaning.
  • Distinctions between the goods or services.
  • Relevant commercial circumstances.
  • Any legally available grounds supporting acceptance.

In appropriate cases, consent from the earlier proprietor or evidence supporting honest concurrent use may require consideration under Sections 17(5) and 19.

However, consent and honest concurrent use are not automatic remedies.

Sample Legal Argument

The applicant submits that the applied-for mark and the cited registered trademark should be assessed in their entireties, having regard to their actual representations and the goods or services concerned.

For the reasons set out below, the applicant submits that the circumstances do not establish the alleged conflict: [insert detailed, evidence-based analysis].

When Is a Simple Reply Not Enough?

Where an earlier registered trademark is identical and covers identical goods or services, an ordinary argument based on differences between the marks may not provide a legally sustainable answer.

The legal position must be examined carefully.

Key Point: A registered trademark objection should be answered through specific legal reasoning, not merely by claiming that the proposed brand is different.

3. Objection for Lack of Distinctiveness

Not every brand name can function as a trademark.

A trademark must be capable of distinguishing one business's goods or services from those of others.

Under Section 14(1)(b), a trademark lacking distinctive character may face refusal.

A Simple Example

  • Imagine a business applies to register BEST QUALITY SHOES for footwear.
  • The Registrar may question whether these words identify a particular business or merely describe the products.
  • Now compare that expression with a genuinely invented word that has no ordinary meaning in relation to footwear.

The invented mark may have a stronger claim to inherent distinctiveness.

How Should You Reply?

First, examine whether the mark is inherently distinctive.

Consider:

  • Does the mark contain an invented word?
  • Does it have an unusual combination of elements?
  • Does it identify a particular commercial source?
  • Is the wording descriptive of the goods or services?
  • Has the mark acquired distinctiveness through use?

If the mark contains genuinely distinctive elements, explain their relevance.

If the applicant relies on acquired distinctiveness, supporting evidence becomes important.

What Evidence May Help?

Depending on the circumstances, evidence may include:

  • Sales Invoices: Dated invoices showing use of the mark.
  • Product Packaging: Packaging displaying the trademark.
  • Advertising Records: Promotional materials featuring the brand.
  • Business Documents: Records establishing relevant commercial use.
  • Sales Information: Data connected with the mark.
  • Consumer Recognition: Reliable evidence showing that consumers associate the mark with a particular commercial source.

Under the relevant proviso to Section 14, acquired distinctiveness through use must satisfy the statutory requirements, including the relevant pre-application timing.

Sample Legal Argument

The applicant submits that the applied-for trademark possesses distinctive character when considered as a whole in relation to the specified goods or services.

Alternatively, where applicable, the applicant relies upon the evidence of use annexed to this reply to demonstrate that the mark had acquired distinctive character before the application date.

What Should You Avoid?

Do not claim acquired distinctiveness merely because the applicant has used a name for several years.

The evidence must establish the legally relevant facts.

Key Point: Actual evidence is more useful than unsupported statements about brand popularity.

4. Objection Based on Geographical Terms

A geographical name may create a different trademark problem.

For example, an applicant may attempt to register an expression that directly describes the geographical origin of particular goods.

Under Section 14(1)(c), a mark consisting exclusively of indications that may describe geographical origin can face an objection.

What Should You Examine?

Before preparing a reply, consider:

  1. Does the geographical term describe where the goods originate?
  2. Does the expression identify a characteristic of the goods or services?
  3. Is the geographical wording part of a larger distinctive trademark?
  4. Is the term associated with a protected geographical indication?
  5. Is any relevant exception supported by the facts?

Where a protected geographical indication is involved, additional legal protections may apply.

How Should You Reply?

Depending on the circumstances, the applicant may explain:

  • Why the expression is not merely descriptive.
  • Why the mark has distinctive character as a whole.
  • Whether a relevant statutory exception applies.
  • What supporting evidence establishes the applicant's position.

Sample Legal Argument

The applicant respectfully submits that the geographical expression appearing in the applied-for trademark does not, in the context of the mark as a whole and the specified goods or services, function exclusively as an indication of geographical origin for the following reasons: [insert factual explanation].

The applicant therefore requests reconsideration of the objection under Section 14.

Important: Adding another word or logo to a geographical expression does not automatically make the resulting trademark registrable.

5. Other Common Objections

Not every Show Cause Notice involves a cited trademark.

Sometimes the Registrar identifies an issue that requires clarification or amendment rather than a detailed argument against an earlier mark.

Descriptive Words

A trademark may face an objection if it simply describes the quality, purpose or characteristics of a product.

Section 14 may be relevant in such circumstances.

How to respond:

  • Identify any genuinely distinctive elements.
  • Explain why the mark is not exclusively descriptive, where applicable.
  • Provide evidence of acquired distinctiveness if a legally available exception is being relied upon.

Disclaimer Requirements

Some trademarks contain words or elements that are common to the trade.

Section 21 deals with registration subject to a disclaimer in specified circumstances.

A disclaimer may limit the claim to exclusive rights over particular non-distinctive matter.

How to respond:

  • Identify the element mentioned in the objection.
  • Examine whether a disclaimer is legally appropriate.
  • Consider the effect of the proposed disclaimer.
  • Submit an appropriate response or amendment where justified.

A disclaimer does not automatically resolve every objection involving the trademark as a whole.

Application Defects

Sometimes the objection concerns the application rather than the brand itself.

For example, the Registrar may require clarification of the goods or services specification.

How to respond:

  1. Identify the specific defect.
  2. Check the relevant filing requirements.
  3. Prepare the necessary clarification or amendment.
  4. Submit the required documents through the accepted procedure.

A lengthy explanation about brand reputation will not necessarily answer a technical filing defect.

The rule is simple: Answer the objection that has actually been raised.

How to Prepare Your Reply

Once you understand the objection, preparing the response becomes easier.

A useful legal reply should follow a clear and logical structure.

Step 1 – Identify the Application

Start with the basic details:

  • Trademark application number.
  • Trademark name or representation.
  • Trademark class.
  • Applicant's full name.
  • Date of the Show Cause Notice.

Make sure these details match the application record.

Step 2 – State the Objection

  • Identify the legal provision relied upon by the Registrar.
  • If an earlier trademark has been cited, mention its application or registration number.
  • Do not misstate or alter the actual objection.

Step 3 – Explain Your Position

  • State the relevant facts supporting your application.
  • For example, if you dispute similarity between two trademarks, explain the differences that are legally relevant.
  • Avoid emotional arguments, unnecessary statements and unsupported claims.

Step 4 – Apply the Law

  • Connect the facts to the relevant provisions of the Trade Marks Ordinance, 2001.
  • Explain why the objection should be reconsidered in light of those provisions.
  • Do not simply quote legal sections without applying them to the facts.

Step 5 – Attach Evidence

Include relevant supporting documents.

Depending on the objection, these may include:

  • Trademark records.
  • Business documents.
  • Dated invoices.
  • Advertising materials.
  • Product packaging.
  • Consent documents, where applicable.
  • Other relevant supporting records.

Explain what each document is intended to establish.

Step 6 – Make Your Request

  • Conclude with a clear request to the Registrar.
  • Where legally justified, request reconsideration of the objection and permission for the application to proceed.
  • Where appropriate, request an opportunity of hearing.

Sample Show Cause Notice Reply

The following example demonstrates how a response may be structured where the Registrar has cited an earlier trademark.

This is an educational sample, not a ready-to-file legal defence.

The arguments must be adjusted according to the specific objection, applicable law and supporting evidence.

Sample Legal Reply Format

BEFORE THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS

TRADE MARKS REGISTRY

Subject: Reply to Show Cause Notice

Application No.: [Application Number]

Trademark: [Applied-for Mark]

Class: [Class Number]

Applicant: [Applicant's Full Name]

Notice Date: [Date]

RESPECTFULLY SUBMITTED:

1. Preliminary Submission

That the applicant filed the above-mentioned trademark application seeking registration of the mark [MARK] for the goods or services specified in the application.

2. Examination Objection

That the Trade Marks Registry has raised an objection under Section [Relevant Section] of the Trade Marks Ordinance, 2001, citing Trademark No. [Cited Trademark Number].

3. Applicant's Response

That the applicant respectfully submits the following response to the objection.

4. Comparison of Trademarks

That the applied-for trademark and the cited trademark are [insert accurate factual comparison concerning appearance, pronunciation, meaning and other relevant characteristics].

5. Goods or Services

That the respective goods or services are [insert actual specifications and any legally relevant distinctions].

6. Supporting Evidence

That the applicant relies upon the following facts and supporting documents: [identify the evidence and explain its relevance].

7. Legal Submissions

That, having regard to the applicable legal provisions and the facts stated above, the applicant respectfully submits that [insert the specific legal basis for reconsideration].

PRAYER

In view of the foregoing submissions, it is respectfully requested that the objection may kindly be reconsidered and the application be allowed to proceed in accordance with law.

In the alternative, the applicant requests an opportunity of hearing before the Registrar.

Applicant / Authorized Representative

Name: [Name]

Signature: [Signature]

Date: [Date]

Annexures: [List supporting documents]

Can You Use This Reply for Every Objection?

No. Every objection requires its own legal assessment.

The sample provides a general structure only.

For example:

  • Pending Trademark: Examine the status, priority, similarity and statutory relevance of the cited application.
  • Registered Trademark: Address earlier rights and the applicable grounds for refusal.
  • Distinctiveness: Explain inherent distinctiveness or legally relevant acquired distinctiveness.
  • Geographical Terms: Address the specific geographical or descriptive objection.
  • Application Defects: Provide the required clarification or amendment.

Copying a sample without understanding the objection may leave the Registrar's concerns unanswered.

Remember: A strong reply is not necessarily a long reply. It is one that addresses the actual objection with sound legal reasoning and relevant evidence.

How to Submit Your Reply

Preparing a legal response and submitting it are two separate tasks.

Once your reply is ready, follow the procedure applicable to your application.

Step 1 – Check the Notice

Read the filing instructions issued by the Registry.

Confirm whether your particular response must be submitted through an available electronic facility, physically or by another accepted method.

Step 2 – Prepare the Documents

Arrange the documents required for your response.

These may include:

  • Written legal reply.
  • Supporting annexures.
  • Application details.
  • Required authorization, where applicable.
  • Any prescribed form or fee relevant to the action being taken.

Check that all information is accurate.

Step 3 – Confirm the Filing Method

IPO provides online trademark filing facilities for self-applicants and authorized representatives.

However, the availability of online trademark applications does not necessarily establish that every examination response can be filed through the same system.

Confirm the currently accepted method for the particular Show Cause Notice through the Registry or its official guidance.

Step 4 – Submit Within the Deadline

Submit the required response, amendment or hearing request within the applicable period.

Where a prescribed form, signature, authorization or fee is required, comply with that requirement.

Step 5 – Keep Proof of Submission

After filing, preserve:

  1. A complete copy of the reply.
  2. All supporting annexures.
  3. Official acknowledgment or receipt.
  4. Relevant correspondence.
  5. Any subsequent communication from the Registry.

Do not assume that merely drafting a reply or sending an informal email means that the response has been officially filed.

For current procedural information, visit the official IPO website.

What Happens After Submission?

Submitting a reply does not guarantee trademark registration.

The Registrar must consider whether the response adequately addresses the objection.

Depending on the circumstances, the Registry may:

  1. Accept the explanation.
  2. Require additional information or clarification.
  3. Allow an appropriate amendment.
  4. Arrange a hearing.
  5. Issue an adverse decision.

Under Section 27, an application may proceed where the applicable legal requirements are satisfied.

If accepted, the application may move towards advertisement in the Trade Marks Journal and subsequent statutory stages.

A third party may still challenge an application through a separate opposition proceeding after the relevant advertisement.

Learn more in our trademark opposition guide.

Missed the Deadline?

  • Suppose you filed your trademark application several months ago.
  • You received the Show Cause Notice but did not reply.
  • When you finally check the application status, you discover that it has been treated as abandoned.

Is everything lost?

Not necessarily, but prompt action is important.

Can an Application Be Restored?

Rule 27(3) of the Trade Marks Rules, 2004 provides a restoration mechanism in specified circumstances.

An applicant seeking restoration must show sufficient cause to the satisfaction of the Registrar and comply with the prescribed procedure.

This includes an application on Form TM-57, accompanied by a statement of case, subject to the applicable requirements and time limits.

What Should You Do?

If your application has been treated as abandoned:

  1. Obtain the official application status.
  2. Verify the date on which the objection was communicated.
  3. Examine the relevant procedural dates.
  4. Check whether restoration remains available.
  5. Prepare the required application and supporting explanation where justified.

Important: Restoration is not automatic. Submitting a late reply alone should not be assumed to revive an abandoned application.

Mistakes That Can Cost You

Many applicants face avoidable problems because they misunderstand the examination process.

1. Ignoring the Notice

A trademark application does not necessarily remain active indefinitely without the required response.

2. Using a Copied Reply

A generic reply may fail to answer the particular objection raised by the Registrar.

3. Ignoring a Pending Trademark

An earlier pending application may still be legally relevant under Section 18(2).

4. Claiming the Marks Are Different Without Explanation

Simply stating that two marks are different is not enough.

The response should address the legally relevant characteristics of the marks and the goods or services.

5. Relying Only on Trademark Classes

Different classes do not necessarily eliminate the possibility of a legal conflict.

6. Claiming Ownership Without Evidence

Business use and trademark rights must be assessed under the applicable law.

7. Failing to Keep Filing Records

Applicants should preserve reliable proof of the documents filed and the date of submission.

The strongest reply is not necessarily the longest one. It is the reply that answers the actual objection with sound reasoning and relevant evidence.

Can Foreign Applicants Reply?

Yes. Foreign businesses and overseas trademark applicants may need to respond when their applications are examined by IPO.

A foreign trademark registration does not automatically overcome an objection raised under Pakistan's trademark law.

What Should International Applicants Check?

International applicants should verify:

  • Correct legal ownership of the trademark.
  • Relevant application and priority particulars.
  • The statutory grounds cited by the Registrar.
  • Local correspondence arrangements.
  • Applicable representation requirements.
  • Any necessary authorization for an appointed representative.

Where a legal representative is appointed, the relevant procedural requirements should also be addressed.

The same principle applies to local and international applicants: The reply must answer the domestic legal objection raised against the application.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a Show Cause Notice a rejection?

No. A Show Cause Notice is an examination-stage communication requiring action. It does not automatically mean the application has been finally rejected.

Can I reply without a lawyer?

An applicant may make representations personally, subject to the applicable procedure.

However, objections involving earlier trademark rights, complex similarity issues or legal evidence may benefit from professional assistance.

How long do I have to reply?

Rule 27 generally provides two months from communication of the objection for the required action.

Always verify the applicable deadline and instructions in your notice.

Is a written reply enough?

Not always.

Depending on the circumstances, the Registrar may require additional information, an amendment or a hearing.

What if the cited trademark is pending?

An earlier pending application may still be legally relevant under Section 18(2).

Its status, priority and relationship to the proposed trademark should be carefully examined.

Do I need to attach evidence?

That depends on the objection.

Arguments concerning acquired distinctiveness, commercial use or other disputed facts may require reliable supporting documents.

Will IPO accept my trademark after the reply?

There is no guarantee.

Acceptance depends on whether the application satisfies the applicable legal requirements after examination of the response.

Before You Give Up on Your Trademark

A Show Cause Notice can feel like a setback, especially when you have already invested time and money in building your brand.

But an objection is not always the end of the registration process.

What matters is understanding the legal issue, preparing an appropriate response and taking action within the prescribed period.

Do not abandon your application simply because you do not understand the notice.

Instead:

  1. Read the notice carefully.
  2. Identify the legal objection.
  3. Examine any cited trademarks.
  4. Gather relevant evidence.
  5. Prepare a legally supported response.
  6. Submit it through the accepted procedure within the applicable deadline.

If the objection involves conflicting trademarks, complex legal issues or an approaching deadline, professional guidance may help you assess the available options.

Need Help with Your Reply?

A.A. Dewan & Co. assists individuals, businesses and international trademark owners with examination objections, cited trademark analysis, legal replies and Trade Marks Registry proceedings.

Our services include:

  • Reviewing trademark Show Cause Notices.
  • Identifying the relevant legal objections.
  • Examining cited pending and registered trademarks.
  • Preparing case-specific legal responses.
  • Reviewing supporting evidence.
  • Assisting with relevant Registry proceedings.

If you have received a Show Cause Notice, you may share the notice, application number, trademark details and available supporting documents for a professional assessment.

Explore our Trademark Registration Services or contact our legal team.

 

Legal References

Trade Marks Ordinance, 2001 — Sections 14, 17, 18, 19, 21 and 27.

Trade Marks Rules, 2004 — Rules 27 and 28.

IPO Trademark FAQs — Examination and Show Cause Notice information.

IPO Online Filing Guidelines — Official online filing account guidance.

Legal Information Notice: This article provides general information about trademark examination proceedings before IPO Pakistan. The sample reply is illustrative and must be adapted to the particular facts, objections and applicable law. It does not replace professional legal advice or guarantee trademark registration.

Legal Guidance

Need case-specific legal guidance in Pakistan?

Every legal matter depends on its facts, documents, dates, and applicable procedure. Contact the firm for a confidential consultation before taking action.

Book Legal Consultation View Services WhatsApp Lawyer

Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!

Leave a Comment